The following is a letter from Lorelei Pulliam, who puts House Bill 1541 / Senate Bill 1026 into perspective. Please don't let this happen. Say NO to House Bill 1541 / Senate Bill 1026 and contact your representative. The vote is tomorrow- Monday, so contact them Monday. Spread the word.
____________________________________________________________
Millions of Lives in Virginia Depend On You!
Two bills have been introduced into the General Assembly of Virginia that are an affront to anyone who cares about or is involved with animals of any kind. For the first time in memory, bills have been introduced that should incense animal lovers, insult farmers, and cause the ordinary citizen of the Commonwealth to recoil at the the very idea that we have abandoned all humanity towards our fellow creatures.
These identical bills were written without any input from animal advocates in our state by those wanting to protect their own interests and not those of the animals. Cruelty laws are supposed to protect animals and not make conditions worse.
Imagine having lovingly raised and sold an animal to find it in squalid conditions and being inadequately fed and cared for but not emaciated. Your local animal control officer is helpless to help you and the animal because the law is so weak and vague. Imagine having to drive past a foundered pony every day on the way to work and watch it try and hobble to the creek and down a steep embankment for a simple drink. She manages to keep from becoming dehydrated so there is nothing that can be done to help her.
This is the situation HB 1541 and SB 1026 will create. This is coming up for vote on Monday, January 24 at 5 pm. Time is of the essence to stop them!
What is so wrong with this picture?
Look at this face. He lived in a tiny pen made of clothing shelves without shelter of any kind, adequate food or water in the dead of winter. The straw was provided by the Animal Control Officers to keep them from becoming buried in the cold mud like their brothers and sisters did. Anyone that knows anything about pigs would be aghast to see these poor babies with mud covering their backs in early January. Clearly they had not been burying themselves in the mud to cool off! Under the proposed House Bill 1541 and Senate Bill 1026, there would have been nothing wrong here.
The bodies of their dead siblings that had succumbed to the cold and the mud buried beside them were sustaining them beyond emaciation and dehydration. Under the current law, the owner was required to provide adequate food for their size, age, and species, along with unfozen water at suitable intervals. Such would have to be given to them in an area that protected it from contamination from filth such as feces, which was impossible in the pen that had sucked their brothers and sisters down to their deaths.
It also required that they have adequate shelter. It was under this current law that the owner of these animals was convicted of animal cruelty and sentenced to prison time and fined thousands of dollars.
Under the proposed HB 1541, they only have to receive food and water enough to prevent emaciation and dehydration. There is no mention of even the most elementary needs of any living creature such as shelter or room to move and exercise. Surely we can do better than this!
Below are the current regulations under which prosecutions involving agricultural animals have been succesfully pursued in Virginia. Read them carefully and try and ask youself why anyone who considers themselves a caretaker of any animals would
oppose these provision.
Adequate feed means access to and the provision of food which is of sufficient quantity and nutritive value to maintain each animal in good health; is accessible to each animal; is prepared so as to permit ease of consumption for the age, species, condition, size and type of each animal; is provided in a clean and sanitary manner; is placed so as to minimize contamination by excrement and pests; and is provided at suitable intervals for the species, age, and condition of the animal, but at least once daily, except as prescribed by a veterinarian or as dictated by naturally occurring states of hibernation or fasting normal for the species.
Adequate water is defined as provision of and access to clean, fresh, potable water of a drinkable temperature which is provided in a suitable manner, in sufficient volume, and at suitable intervals, but at least once every twelve hours, to maintain normal hydration for the age, species, condition, size and type of each animal, except as prescribed by a veterinarian or as dictated by naturally occurring states of hibernation or fasting normal for the species; and is provided in clean, durable receptacles which are accessible to each animal and are placed so as to minimize contamination of the water by excrement and pests or an alternative source of hydration consistent with generally accepted husbandry practices.
Adequate shelter is defined provision of and access to shelter that is suitable for the species, age, condition, size, and type of each animal; provides adequate space for each animal; is safe and protects each animal from injury, rain, sleet, snow, hail, direct sunlight, the adverse effects of heat or cold, physical suffering, and impairment of health; is properly lighted; is properly cleaned; enables each animal to be clean and dry, except when detrimental to the species; and, for dogs and cats, provides a solid surface, resting platform, pad, floormat, or similar device that is large enough for the animal to lie on in a normal manner and can be maintained in a sanitary manner. Under this chapter, shelters whose wire, grid, or slat floors (i) permit the animals' feet to pass through the openings, (ii) sag under the animals' weight, or (iii) otherwise do not protect the animals' feet or toes from injury are not adequate shelter. for dogs and cats, provides a solid surface, resting platform, pad, floormat, or similar device that is large enough for the animal to lie on in a normal manner and can be maintained in a sanitary manner. Under this chapter, shelters whose wire, grid, or slat floors (i) permit the animals' feet to pass through the openings, (ii) sag under the animals' weight, or (iii) otherwise do not protect the animals' feet or toes from injury are not adequate shelter.
Is this standard of care good enough?
Here is the food available to these animals seized in King George County. Take a look. If they had just been able to wade through the mud without getting stuck and dying of starvation and hypothermia, this untouched molded bread could have sustained them so that they did not become emaciated , which is the standard set by HB 1541 and SB 1026.
Under these bills, An Act of God would exonerate an owner from providing substance enough to prevent emaciation and dehydration. Perhaps a snowstorm, flash flood, the mud itself, or sprained ankle was to blame here. This standard of care should insult every farmer in the Commonwealth. We owe these animals more than the lack of emaciation and dehydration. Good farmers consider themselves stewards of the land and good shepherds of their herds and flocks. The stockman that mentored me as a youngster would never stand to have themselves of their fellow ranchers to be held to a standard of care as low as the one in HB 1541 and SB 1026.
Thanks to the current laws and the diligence of Animal Control Officers, The Sheriffs Office, and a diligent District Attorney of King George Virginia, all animals were removed from this woman and she was ordered never to own another animal again.
Return to this?
This is the horror that the fifty farm animals removed from King George lived and many died in. For those involved in these type of investigations, this site is not unusual. Under the proposed bills, and incredibly under current law, the former owner is eligible to appeal the judges order that she never again be allowed to own animals after two years. These bills would not take into account that the fact that it was her second conviction. Is that acceptable to you? Whose interest are being served here?
Certainly not the animals or the taxpayers of Virginia who already had to pay for two prosecutions. To those familiar with these type of cases, especially those involving hoarding, recidivism is the norm rather than the exception
Obviously the current law needs to be improved but these bills keep the worst of the old law and water down the protection available to the animals now.
Who would deny them this?
Some of these goats were found huddled next to dead goats that were frozen solid. Under the proposed law, had the dead animals been removed by the owner, there would have been no emaciated animals visible.
Rescuers had to keep fleece vests on the brown and white Boer goat to make up for the poor body condition caused by improper feeding and lack of shelter. She was not considered emaciated but a diet of bread and molded hay had taken a toll. Vets doubted that she would survive but did. All of the goats not only survived but thrived and found new homes with their families intact. This is thanks to a rescue organization that took them all in, rehabilitated them and found homes that promised exemplary care for the remainder of their lives.
Unbelievably, HB 1541 has the option of a rescue organization taking possession of animals seized in abuse and neglect situations stricken off. Instead this bill prefers that they be auctioned off to
the highest bidder. It is incredible to imagine anyone wishing anything but good things to any living creature that has already suffered so much or denying those willing to help them find sanctuary the ability to do so.
It is a slap in the face to every equine and farm animal rescue group in the Commonwealth that have worked so tirelessly for years to save so many.
Tell Your Legislature Who The People of Virginia Are
There is no doubt these are hard times. All of us are experiencing it. It is during times such as these that all animals need more protection and not less. We are not a people who expect the weakest to bear the brunt of the burdens for which they have had no part in the making. Agricultural animals in our state are the most vulnerable and the least protected of any animals. They are literally at our mercy. Let us tell our legislatures and the rest of the world that we are an honorable and humane people. We do protect the weak and the helpless and understand that how we treat the animals under our care is a reflection of who we are and a way by which others judge us. These animals that we are responsible for carry us safely over rocky trails and pack our grandchildren over many miles as they teach lessons that only they can. Through these animals many young people in our state learn to understand what responsibility and commitment are. Some bring us companionship and a shoulder to cry on. Thousands upon thousands give up their very lives to become food on our tables.
Let us loudly reject those who wish to push the standard of care for these animals lower to appease the profit margins of the powerful and wealthy agribusinesses.
This is not a plea for fundraising of any kind nor is it tied to any animal welfare group. This is not an attempt to get people to stop eating meat or change their lifestyles in any way. This is a plea from the heart of one person for the animals. Our laws to protect them need to be strengthened. Each and every animal in these pictures suffered from and survived the worst abuse and neglect imaginable. The pig pictured above is with me. She was so weak from weeks of being out in the cold without shelter or adequate food and water when she was rescued that animal control considered euthanizing her. It took her months to learn to trust humans. She now lives in a loving home as a pet with four other pigs from the same rescue. It is for them that we must prevail in stopping HB 1541.
If the authors of HB 1541 had any interest in protecting animals or even a good first step in that direction,
they would have invited to the table those in the trenches of animal rescue and advocacy.
Please share this post and this message with everyone you can. Time is of the essence- it is up for vote Monday, January 24 at 5 pm. Alert your local media and send a message to Richmond through your legislature that we do not do business this way in Virginia with our animals.
To find out how to contact your legislature, click on the link in the article below or cut and paste:
http://legis.state.va.us/1_cit_guide/contacting_my.html
Mrs. Terry Smith
100 Main Street
Anytown, VA 23222
Dear Senator or Mr. or Mrs. (for Delegate)____________:
I am writing to you because I am concerned about HB 1541. I am in favor of protection for the agricultural animals in our state and this bill does not provide adequate protection worthy of the name.
Please vote against this measure when it comes before the Senate/House.
Sincerely,
Terry
Mrs. Terry Smith
It is time to make a stand for these animals that truly are the least of the beasts on this planet of ours. It is time to take a stand for compassion and mercy for those that we share this world with.
Lorelei Pulliam
Afton Virginia
"But what would we most yearn for if we were locked away in dark little pens and stalls and ignored or shouted at and treated like garbage? I for one would yearn most for the sun and the cool water the sun and the cool water and the breeze and fellowship of my kind. I would yearn to be seen, feeling that if others only saw me they would try to help." Mathew Sculley - Dominion